This photo shows an exterior view of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit building in Washington, D.C., from 2002
Paul J. via Getty Images Richards/AFP
hide caption
toggle caption
Paul J. via Getty Images Richards/AFP
A federal judge who was sidelined for three years because of questions about her qualifications is asking the Supreme Court to give her life. Judge Pauline Newman is 98 years old – and she wants the chance to hear cases again.
His story highlights an aging judiciary, where the average age of federal jurists is 69 years old. Life tenure now raises thorny questions about retirement.
Newman joined the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in 1984 during the Reagan era. She soon became a star in the small community of patent law watchers.
Former colleague Paul Mitchell said Newman is more or less the same as before – but the court around her has changed. It has become more skeptical of patents.

“He’s extremely talented, very hard-working and very independent,” said Mitchell, who served with Newman for 22 years. “She is slow to write opinions and that irritates some judges, and she dissents more often than any other judge, and that also irritates some judges.”
These disagreements came to a head in March 2023, when the chief justice of his court launched an investigation. Newman was 95 years old at the time.
Appellant The court wanted to ascertain his fitness to serve. But Judge Newman refused to sit in on the examination with experts selected by the court. Her lawyer said she wanted to choose her own doctors, who gave her a clean bill of health.
“The idea that he is incapable of performing his judicial duties is nonsense,” said his attorney, John Vecchione, senior litigation counsel for the nonprofit. New Civil Liberties Alliance.
To date, no court has found that Newman is incompetent. That question has been put on hold while lawyers debate whether the judge got due process. It’s been a long time coming off the bench, Vecchione said.
“I mean, there have been people who committed sexual harassment, there have been people who manipulated their…expenses,” he said. “There’s all kinds of stupid activity, alcohol, all kinds of things and people who haven’t been kept off the bench for as long as Judge Newman have done nothing wrong.”

Newman says it’s about principle
According to former colleagues, Newman has been speaking at conferences, attending legal events and writing during her lengthy suspension.
In a recent video produced by her legal team, she said she is fighting on principle.
youtube
Newman said, “I thought it was ridiculous and that I should not be caving to judicial colleagues or setting a pattern that enables people to bully, intimidate, and coerce a colleague who writes a dissent they don’t like.”
This month, he asked the Supreme Court Examine and evaluate his claims that he has been denied due process. This is a far-fetched idea as the High Court takes only a small portion of the cases each session.
The Federal Circuit, where Newman once heard cases, declined to comment for this story. So did the Justice Department, which is defending the court in this bitter dispute.
But an internal committee hearing claims about judicial conduct and disability rejected Newman’s due process claims in a March 24 decision. The committee included some of the most highly respected judges in the federal system. their ruling Newman was said to enjoy an office in the courthouse, employ a law clerk and receive salary and benefits.
He wrote, “Judge Newman cannot be deprived of a property interest in the office which he still occupies.”
Their decision concluded by saying that the committee expected Newman to undergo further medical evaluation.

Big questions regarding judicial age
Michigan State University political scientist Ryan Black said the Newman case signals something larger about the federal court system.
“Judges are being appointed younger and serving longer,” Black said.
According to federal court system statistics, more than 30% of federal judges are 75 years of age or older.

Black said his research showed that older judges rely more on their clerks — and may need more support from colleagues.
“The story is quite clear that as judges age, there is a measurable, reliable empirical decline in many aspects of their performance,” he said.
His former colleague, Paul Mitchell, says Newman is clear and firm. Mitchell, who retired more than 15 years ago, personally supports a retirement age for judges, like many in other professions.
“Surgeons, airline pilots, many people with sensitive jobs have to stop at a certain age set by the authorities, whether or not they want to continue or whether they are able to continue,” he said.
The question for the Supreme Court is whether the judges are different?
