It’s not often that Keir Starmer’s allies believe they have Nigel Farage and Kemi Badenoch – but on Iran, they think he is on the right side of history and public opinion.
“It could have been done by him,” said Emily Thornberry, the Labor chair of the foreign affairs committee, who was out of the blocks for saying she thought Donald Trump’s attacks on Iran were illegal. “You’ve never had a British prime minister say no to an American president since Vietnam. That’s a big deal.”
Since the devastating disasters of Iraq and Afghanistan, the prospect of helping a U.S. effort to facilitate regime change in another foreign country has been extremely unpopular with the public.
Starmer sought a middle ground – refusing to allow the US to operate from British bases for initial attacks, but later allowing them to be used for defensive action to destroy Iranian missiles. This has earned him Trump’s ire and public approval in Britain, and has won over many within the Labor Party, who believe he is acting more in line with his political instincts.
One Labor MP said that Starmer’s decision to become even more critical of US attacks on Iran several days later had made him feel that he “recognised this guy as the real Starmer – closer to Robin Cook than Tony Blair” on these matters.
In contrast, Farage and Badenoch were quick to say that Starmer was not doing enough to support joint US and Israeli attacks. When the conflict began the Reform UK leader said: “We must do everything we can to support the operation.”
However, as gasoline prices rose and public opinion hardened against the war last week, both adjusted their positions. A YouGov poll this week found six in 10 Britons are opposed to military action, while a quarter are in favor of it.
Badenoch now denies that she wanted Britain to get involved in the war and that she only wanted Britain to help take out Iranian missiles. Meanwhile, Farage pulled a stunt by promising a 25p discount on a liter of fuel at a petrol station and claiming: “If we can’t even defend Cyprus, let’s not get ourselves into another foreign war.”
One senior Tory said: “We just seem confused and the messaging has been terrible. But most of us on the right actually believe that Starmer was completely wrong not to support Trump at the beginning, so the right thing to do would be to stick to our guns, no matter what the public says.”
Veteran Conservative and former Deputy Foreign Secretary Andrew Mitchell said rejecting Trump’s request was a “huge mistake” and would prove that Starmer has not acted in the UK’s national interest in the long run.
He said, “America is our closest ally and friend, and when the President asked for our help with the use of joint bases – essentially he wanted them to refuel – the answer should have been yes.” “It is truly shameful that Starmer said no based on questionable legal advice, thus demonstrating that Starmer is a lawyer, not a political leader.”
Although the majority of the public is anti-war, opinion polls show that Conservative voters are almost evenly divided. Reform voters are more likely to support the Iran war than other party supporters, but there is still an isolationist wing on the hard right that is attracted to the message of Rupert Lowe – a former Reform MP who now sits as an independent – that this is “not our fight”. It appears that the risks of appearing pro-war and pro-Trump have forced both sides to control their initial messaging.
But Alan Mendoza, Reform’s chief adviser on global affairs and executive director of the right-wing Henry Jackson Society think tank, said the party still believed Starmer had refused Trump’s request, and he said Farage had been consistent throughout.
“When the United States asked this question on the first day, he would have said yes. And of course, he would have also made sure, first of all, that British bases were protected,” Mendoza said. He said that no one in Britain was ever suggesting or favoring aggressive bombing action or engaging in a ground invasion.
He also questioned whether the surveys were asking the right questions about support for Iranian military action, and suggested that asking questions about whether it is in Britain’s strategic interest to support an ally would generate more positive responses.
However, those in Downing Street are confident they have got the strategy right on this, with internal polling showing support for Starmer’s approach. A senior Downing Street figure said: “(Reform Mayor) Andrea Jenkins is absolutely on the wrong side of not ruling out the possibility of boots on the ground.”
Labor conditions are also helpful in explaining any potential impact on the cost of living. He said, “Obviously how people assign blame is a multidimensional thing, but we can turn around and say, this is why we don’t think we should get involved in the Middle East.”
Other senior Labor MPs are wondering whether Starmer would have taken the same decision to blockade the US using military bases if Peter Mandelson was still ambassador to the US and his colleague Morgan McSweeney was still chief of staff.
Ben Judah, his former adviser when David Lammy was Foreign Secretary, said that the right-wing parties had got into trouble because they “basically on day one decided to use that old card of ‘Have you failed in the special relationship?’ Trying to curse the Prime Minister”.
He added: “I think, because of their own leadership’s foreign policy inexperience and lack of curiosity about the world beyond Westminster, they were anticipating that this would be a Venezuela-style overnight story. And in fact, this is a week-long, deeply disruptive event in the world economy that voters are really concerned about, and at the petrol pump. And you’re seeing them changing positions.”
He said that for the Tories it has come from the party “now that they are in opposition and losing that kind of foreign policy power”, and that Farage “has an America problem”.
“Trump 2.0 is not governing (the way) he campaigned,” Judah said. “He campaigned on an isolationist platform, he literally campaigned on bringing world peace.
“We have seen an effort to professionalize reform and become a genuinely competitive Conservative party, from the old type of Ukip separatists to a more type of neocon, pro-American stance.
“This kind of neocon tradition in the UK is one thing when America is behaving in a way that is good for your politician, praising him, or when America is perceived as being fast or moving forward, but now it has become a problem for him.”
However, not everyone within the Cabinet is unanimous on whether Britain’s strategy will ultimately prove to be the right one. While an unprecedented leak to the Spectator of a National Security Council meeting revealed that Ed Miliband, Rachel Reeves and Yvette Cooper strongly supported blocking the US from using UK military bases, at least one senior Cabinet minister is worried that the long-term impact on transatlantic relations would be devastating to the UK’s position and security.
Thornberry is more confident that the relationship will work out. “We will always be close to the United States,” he said. “They are our closest allies. But at times you may disagree. We survived Vietnam, we will survive this. And it’s not that we haven’t been led by them in some very disastrous decisions in the recent past.
“People – well, men especially – get particularly excited about wars, and in the beginning it’s quite popular. And then, when they start to think about what it means and what its effects are, as the war starts to affect daily life, the war starts to lose popularity in a way. You don’t have to live that long to experience the Middle East wars. You know, we know how that goes.”
