Jonathan Kitchen/Getty Images
Artificial intelligence has come into the field of mental health. Large health systems and independent physicians have begun adopting various AI tools to manage mental health treatment.
The pace of adoption – coupled with troubling incidents of individuals using general-use AI chatbots with disastrous consequences – is causing some concern among practitioners and researchers.

“There is a lot of fear and anxiety about AI,” says the psychologist. vale wrightSenior director of health care innovation at the American Psychological Association (APA). “And there are fears in particular about AI replacing jobs.”
Those concerns were a major issue last month, When 2,400 mental health care providers at Kaiser Permanente in Northern California and the Central Valley went on a 24-hour strike.
Triage through technology and low paid staff
is one of the doctors who went on strike Ilana Marcucci-Morris.
Since 2019, Marcucci-Morris worked as a triage physician in Kaiser Permanente’s telepsychiatry intake hub. But this changed in May 2025.
“I’ve been reassigned from triage to other duties,” says Marcucci-Morris, a licensed clinical social worker based at KP in Oakland, California.
She says her change in role was inspired by KP’s efforts to improve its triage system.
“What was always a 10 to 15-minute screening from a licensed physician like me is now being conducted according to a script by unlicensed operators,” she says. “Or, an e-visit.”
He and his colleagues worry that downsizing triage systems is paving the way for AI to take their jobs.
At Kaiser Permanente in Walnut Creek, California, the triage team of nine providers has been reduced to three Harimandir KhalsaA marriage and family therapist who also works as a triage physician.
“The work that we did (is) being handled by these telephone service representatives,” says Khalsa.
A 24-hour strike on 18 March protested these changes, among other things.
“Part of our unfair labor practice strike is really about the erosion of licensed triage within the health plan,” Marcucci-Morris says.
“At Kaiser Permanente, our use of AI does not replace clinical expertise,” said Lionel Sims, senior vice president of human resources at Kaiser Permanente Northern California. Said In a statement to NPR.
The health system, which is both a direct care provider and insurer, confirmed to NPR that it is assessing an AI tool from a UK company called Limbic.
“We are currently evaluating the use of Limbic to help members access care. Limbic is not in use at this time,” the statement said.
More AI in mental health
“I haven’t yet seen any jobs in mental health care being replaced by AI,” says Wright of the American Psychological Association. Instead, she says, the growing acceptance of AI in mental health care is mostly limited to certain types of tasks.
“One clear positive use of AI tools is in their use to improve efficiency around documentation and other automated types of activities,” she says.
Such as billing insurance companies or updating electronic health records – time-consuming tasks that irritate physicians.
“Most providers want to help people and when they get bogged down in excessive paperwork or documentation to get paid, it takes time away from direct patient care,” says Wright. “And so I think there are benefits to incorporating these tools into your practice depending on your personal comfort level.”
New businesses create a new market
There are about 40 different products for providers with transcription and other “documentation support” services, she says.
one such company is outlineAn AI assistant that summarizes sessions, updates electronic health records, and helps individual physicians track patient progress.
Other companies are building AI tools for larger health systems. For example, limbic Large health systems have created AI assistants to perform a variety of tasks, including intake and patient support.
“We are deployed in 63% of the UK National Health Service and we currently serve patients in 13 US states,” says founder and CEO Ross Harper. A limbic chatbot, called Limbic Care, is trained on cognitive behavioral therapy skills and provides direct assistance to the patient.
“Let’s imagine you’re a person,” says Harper. “It’s 3 a.m. on a Wednesday. You can’t sleep and you think, ‘I might really need some help.'”
In such a scenario, the patient can instantly connect with Limbic Care on the patient portal.
“What Limbic Care will do is provide evidence-based cognitive behavioral therapy tools and techniques so you can really start working on the challenges that you’re experiencing,” says Harper.
Clinical use of AI is not yet widespread
Despite the adoption of AI tools for administrative tasks by health systems and mental health care providers, “we are not seeing a lot of clinical use of AI today,” the psychiatrist says. Dr. John TorrasDirector of digital psychiatry at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center in Boston.
He says one reason is that although AI tools are exciting, “they have not been well tested.”
Plus, “these systems can be very expensive to run,” he says. “You need a big IT team. You need infrastructure. Security things have to be in place.”
He says most small mental health practices and community mental health centers do not have the infrastructure or expertise to use these AI platforms.
APA’s Wright agrees. “At this point, because there is so little regulation, it is imperative to do hard work and research on the provider to find out, ‘Are the devices that are on the market and available, safe and effective?’” she says.
A future of ‘hybrid’ care
However, Torus predicts that AI adoption will continue to grow as the technology improves.
“I think AI is going to change the future of mental health care for the better,” he says. “But as a clinical community we have to learn to use it and work for it. So that means a lot more training. We have to skill ourselves.”
He further said that refusing to use technology is no longer an option. “Because if you take this approach and companies come out with products that may be good, maybe really bad, and even dangerous, we won’t know how to evaluate them.”
In fact, involving mental health care professionals in the development of AI tools will help improve them, Torras says.
Striking mental health workers at Kaiser Permanente in Northern California and the Central Valley want to see their employer do the same — involve them in the development and implementation of AI tools.
“If AI is used, we should not take physicians away from the human process of engaging with our patients in determining the right level of care,” says Khalsa.
As technology becomes more useful to mental health care providers, Torus thinks human providers will likely work closely with AI assistants.
“We’re probably moving toward what’s called a hybrid or blended model of care,” he says. Providers will still treat patients and provide therapy, while AI assistants or chatbots help patients do therapy homework, practice skills, and give providers “real-time feedback” on patients.
The APA’s Vale Wright sees a continuing role for flesh-and-blood physicians. “And that’s because there are no AI digital solutions that can replace human-driven psychotherapy or care.”
