If you look at the more than 16,400 comments posted on the federal government’s website, you get the impression that a large number of elderly Americans are demanding that federal officials increase what they pay for their Medicare Advantage health insurance plans.
Yet about 82% of the comments are identical to the letter that appeared on a secret advocacy group’s website. Medicare Advantage MajorityA data analysis by KFF Health News found.
“Money earned by doing dishonest thingsThe group doesn’t disclose its funders or anything else — except to say it’s “dedicated to protecting and strengthening Medicare Advantage” and “powered by hundreds of thousands of local advocates across the country.”
“Our campaign provides information and tools for concerned Americans to reach decision makers,” spokesman Darren Grubb said in an email. According to it, the group has spent more than $3.1 million on hundreds of Facebook ads since September 2024 facebook ad libraryA database of a social media company’s online advertisements.
There’s no doubt that health insurers are unhappy with this January proposal from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, or CMS, to keep Medicare Advantage reimbursement rates essentially flat through 2027 — far less than they expected from the Trump administration.
Medicare Advantage plans offer seniors a private alternative to Original Medicare. Enroll about insurance plans 35 million Members, more than half, are eligible for Medicare.
CMS is set to announce final rate decisions early next month. The agency requested public comments On offer from 26 January to 25 February to give interested parties and the public a chance to express their views. As of March 12, CMS said it had received 46,884 comments but only 16,422 were posted online.
The Medicare Advantage Majority, which says the rate proposal amounts to “cuts” in services and warns of serious consequences for seniors, accounted for at least 13,522 of the 16,422 published comments as of March 12.
Critics warn that these types of campaigns can create a misleading impression of grassroots support, especially when it is not clear who is funding them.
“It puts a different twist on the huge base of observations that shows it’s all being driven by a specific organization,” said Michael Beckel, director of money in politics reform for Issue One, a group that attempts to limit the influence of money on government policy and legislation.
