return back
valerie does it all
season 3
episode 4
Editor’s Rating
Val’s character has developed her own identity, but the show hasn’t decided its stance on AI.
Photo: Erin Simkin/HBO
It would be quite easy for a satire like Hollywood return back To transform Valerie Cherish into a demonic diva. Instead, she comes across as a relatably flawed person whose constant need for validation sometimes overpowers her better instincts. Over the first two seasons, we saw her frequent self-obsession blind her to the needs of the people she was closest to. Then came a true act of self-sacrifice in the season two finale – it was a moment of tremendous growth for a character who seemed stuck, and in season three, we’re seeing a more developed Val. Now if he is being stopped, it is less because of his own failures and more because of the failures of those around him. This change in formula creates new episodes return back Compelling to watch, even if the season’s big-picture story is a bit complicated.
Case in point: the filming of how’s that?! “Valerie Does It All” reflects one of my big issues so far with the pilot season in what it’s trying to say about AI. The live taping shows viewers a cold open space in which Beth sneezes and a piece of the bed and breakfast she was dusting falls off. Beth says, “I thought I was the only thing that barely stayed here,” and while Josh laughs a little too loudly, the audience does not. Val and Jimmy both agree that they need a big shock to end the scene. Josh, looking like he’s about to cry, defends the line and refuses to rewrite it. Marco’s suggestion that “I’m very surprised the house is falling apart” is no joke either. Ultimately, they go with the AI-scripted “Well, I guess they’re ants. Were Termite.” No, it’s not laugh-out-loud funny, but it’s pretty solid and undeniably better than what the human writer came up with. i know return back This isn’t really making the case for an AI sitcom, and I don’t need every beat of the show to attest to my dislike of the technology. But I’m not entirely sure what we’re supposed to take away from this scene – especially since it follows a scene from last week in which Val and Jimmy both love a new scene written by Al, which Josh dismisses as overly sentimental. The show seems to waver on a key question: Is AI an existential threat because it’s too good or because it’s not good enough?
Thankfully, the next scene gets to the heart of the problem with artificial intelligence. Once they completed reshoots, Jimmy told Val that he would not be directing any more episodes. He argues that the show could never become truly great without real writers. Jimmy says, “The machine is fast and cooperative, I’ll give that, but I saw every one of those jokes coming and so do you.” “Surprises only happen when a group of writers are sitting in a corner beating themselves up over coming up with a better joke.” Experienced director, who has long been the voice of reason return backExplains that you need “broken beautiful souls” of writers to take their pain and create something brilliant and unexpected. That’s saying it a bit thickly, but I appreciate the show’s clear expression that humanity, no matter how flawed, will always triumph over the machines. While the rest of the episode takes a broader approach to satirizing the limitations of AI, Jimmy’s solemn parting words say it all. Meanwhile, Lisa Kudrow continues to make incredible facial expressions as she reacts to everything he says, clearly hurt by hearing all this from someone she respects so deeply. When Jimmy explains that he walks away from any project he’s not having fun with, Val asks if that’s not fun, and I honestly thought I might start crying again. (We’re thinking Kudrow is Amy!) It’s the show that’s the problem, Jimmy assures her. “This is also a matter of shame,” he adds. “That was a really good part for you. That’s how it could have been.” Oops.
While Val was reshooting, Mark was having drinks with Fernando, the building’s doorman, whom he had decided to befriend. He returns home upset, and it’s hard to watch his dirty attempts to get Val to sleep with him – he keeps calling her Mrs. Berman, which may be because that’s how Fernando calls her, but it seems more like his desperation to reclaim his “head of the household” role. “I hate this new chapter,” he admits in defeat. “I hate this new Mark, so I can relate! Val pushed him away; She is distracted reading the script of the next episode how’s that?!Which has some very serious issues. At the table reading the next day, she brings up her concerns: Why are the rest of the cast barely in the episode? Who is this new character, Nathan Drake? And most importantly, why is Beth in jail? The new director, Brian, is not much help, telling Val that they should let the crew build the prison set and then see how it goes. But Val says that there should be no prison system at all. They’re spending money on something that makes no sense, and as executive producer, it’s his job to point that out. In a great visual gag, crew members walk by with a piece of the new set and Val is briefly framed as if he is behind bars. By ignoring the red flags and moving forward with the show, she has found herself in a prison of her own making.
Val meets with tech guy Evan, who is assigned to troubleshoot any problems with Al. He explains that the episode is the result of AI hallucinations, which occur when the program gets confused and glitches. In this case, it misinterpreted Beth’s joke about killing her brother in the pilot and put the character in jail, then added Nathan Drake. unresolved Video-game series. (The role played by Tom Holland in the 2022 film adaptation, which I swear doesn’t exist despite grossing over $400 million.) As soon as Val wakes up to the fact that a glitch in the system has produced an unfilmable episode, she’s fielding complaints from other actors as well. PDP says they have only one view and that is to bake a file into a cake. “Is this a cartoon now?” he asks. I’ll admit that’s how I feel return back It’s plotting AI-hallucinations that are pushing the limits of believability – not that Al would generate something so silly, but no one other than Val would flag it as a serious issue. However, I understand the point the show is trying to make, which is that all the responsibility is falling on his shoulders. This becomes even more apparent when Valerie tries to help Billy, but he is too busy attending. Diversity‘s “50 over 50” photo shoot. It is now up to Val and Val alone to get new scripts from writers.
Unfortunately, Valerie did not get the reaction she was hoping for in the writers’ office. Mary reveals that she and Josh are only there to look after Al and provide credibility to the project, not to do any writing themselves. It seemed obvious from the jump, but it’s news to Val, and it still leaves the problem of the second episode not working. Everyone who can help is either busy or completely disinterested. Faced with an impasse, Val threatens to call the studio, but Mary is not budging. “I’m not going to teach Al to be better,” she replies. “I’m not helping to build the scaffolding that destroys my profession. We took this job because if it worked, it would be a paycheck forever, and now I don’t even care if it works or not.” In fact, Mary seems excited by the prospect of the show failing. After confirming that she and Josh will not be delivering any new episodes, she concludes with “I hope Rome burns to the ground”. This is a thrillingly cheesy performance from Abbi Jacobson. Making fun of him “How’s that?” This is especially upsetting for Valerie.
Out of options, Val finds Billy on the “50 over 50” shoot and tells him that the situation is worse than they thought: “She’s not here to help! She’s here to watch Rome burn!” Billy shows as much concern as he can muster, which isn’t much. When Val demands that he call the studio, he suggests that she explain the situation clearly so he knows what to tell them. In fact, he recorded her rant as a voice note and sent it to NuNet to avoid doing any of the legwork himself. I appreciate that Val is angry – Billy’s behavior gets more extreme every week – even though the worst she can say to him is that he’s really let her down and he’s not being a good productive partner. Jane has a better take: “It was completely disturbing. Who the hell does that guy think he is?” But Valerie, who now understands she’ll have to wear a lot of hats to save the show, is already trying to put a positive spin on the situation. “Sometimes it’s just up to me, and that’s OK,” she says. “I love a challenge. It’s an opportunity to rise to the occasion.” He’ll need to keep that perspective because I have very little confidence that Brandon Wallach is going to save the day.
• In another episode that’s light on jokes, I laughed out loud at the pitch-perfect observational humor of Billy’s “Nobody listens to voice-mail, send me a voice memo.”
• I also like that Mary is writing Inside Out 6: Riley loses her virginity.
• Call me immature, but the very visible artificial scene when Josh was wearing his short shorts – and Val’s subtly horrified reaction – made me laugh. Relatedly, should we infer that Josh and his trainer have an inappropriate relationship? Mary hesitated a little at the mention of her husband’s workout buddy.
• As far as jokes that didn’t work for me in the writers’ office, the assistant below filming the TikTok video feels like another lazy joke on Gen Z, much like Patience’s malignancy.
• While I liked the story of Mark befriending the building staff out of desperation, I was less amused by Fernando trying to start a fight with a warm-up comic at the taping.
• Are we ever going to see an episode of this finance friends? This week, we learned that Mark is in danger of being fired from his job, which leads Valerie to suggest she film with him. She also warns Billy to “never say bad things about Mark.” I hope she’s not reading these recaps.
• Of course, the moment that really jumped out at me was the callback to an overhead camera capturing Val rehearsing the same lines over and over again while distracted by food. After a long day at work, I want to see that.
